Colored Gemstone Engagement Rings

Show your creativity and individuality with alternative wedding and engagement rings and bands. Did you know that until recently, sapphires were the gemstone of choice for engagement rings? These days, the move to alternative gemstones is gaining popularity. 

Not a diamond and little white church kind of person? These unique non-traditional engagement rings are perfect for ANY individual style!

506 products

Tanzanite and Tsavorite Garnet Organic Style Ring

Regular
$2,295.00
Sale
$2,295.00
Regular
Sold Out
Unit Price
per 

Pear Cut Morganite & Diamond Double Halo Ring

Regular
$2,295.00
Sale
$2,295.00
Regular
Sold Out
Unit Price
per 

Emerald-Cut Red Emerald and Diamond Accent Ring

Regular
$2,319.00
Sale
$2,319.00
Regular
Sold Out
Unit Price
per 

Oval Sapphire & Diamond Halo Ring

Regular
$2,339.00
Sale
$2,339.00
Regular
Sold Out
Unit Price
per 

Blue Sapphire Three Stone Oval Ring

Regular
$2,369.00
Sale
$2,369.00
Regular
Sold Out
Unit Price
per 

Fancy Cut London Blue Topaz Milgrain Style Ring

Regular
$2,369.00
Sale
$2,369.00
Regular
Sold Out
Unit Price
per 

Oval Morganite and Diamond Halo Ring

Regular
$2,369.00
Sale
$2,369.00
Regular
Sold Out
Unit Price
per 

Oval Mandarin Garnet & Diamond Halo Split Shank Ring

Regular
$2,369.00
Sale
$2,369.00
Regular
Sold Out
Unit Price
per 

Oval Lotus Garnet & Diamond Ring

Regular
$2,379.00
Sale
$2,379.00
Regular
$2,379.00
Sold Out
Unit Price
per 

Round Cut Tanzanite and Diamond Double Halo Ring

Regular
$2,379.00
Sale
$2,379.00
Regular
Sold Out
Unit Price
per 

Cushion Cut Peridot and Diamond Halo Gold Ring

Regular
$2,379.00
Sale
$2,379.00
Regular
Sold Out
Unit Price
per 
Save 20%

Oval Ruby and Split Shank Diamond Halo Ring

Regular
$2,389.00
Sale
$2,389.00
Regular
$2,985.00
Sold Out
Unit Price
per 

Oval Red Emerald with Diamond Halo Ring

Regular
$2,395.00
Sale
$2,395.00
Regular
Sold Out
Unit Price
per 

Round Garnet & Diamond Halo Ring

Regular
$2,395.00
Sale
$2,395.00
Regular
Sold Out
Unit Price
per 

Mixed Shape Diamond & Round Diamond Halo Style Ring

Regular
$2,395.00
Sale
$2,395.00
Regular
Sold Out
Unit Price
per 

Round Garnet & Diamond Accented Ring

Regular
$2,395.00
Sale
$2,395.00
Regular
Sold Out
Unit Price
per 

Tilted Pear Green Emerald & Diamond Accented Ring

Regular
$2,395.00
Sale
$2,395.00
Regular
Sold Out
Unit Price
per 

Black-Gray Fancy Cut Spinel & Diamond Halo Ring

Regular
$2,409.00
Sale
$2,409.00
Regular
Sold Out
Unit Price
per 

Round Three Blue Sapphire & Diamond Classic Halos Ring

Regular
$2,409.00
Sale
$2,409.00
Regular
Sold Out
Unit Price
per 

East to West Oval Cut Tanzanite and Diamond Accented Ring

Regular
$2,439.00
Sale
$2,439.00
Regular
Sold Out
Unit Price
per 

Fancy Cut Blue Topaz & Diamond Split Shank Ring

Regular
$2,449.00
Sale
$2,449.00
Regular
Sold Out
Unit Price
per 

Cushion-Cut Aquamarine with Diamond Halo Ring

Regular
$2,449.00
Sale
$2,449.00
Regular
Sold Out
Unit Price
per 

Oval Peridot & Classic Diamond Halo Split Shank Ring

Regular
$2,459.00
Sale
$2,459.00
Regular
Sold Out
Unit Price
per 

Moissanite Center Stone & Diamond Accent Engagement Style Ring

Regular
$2,459.00
Sale
$2,459.00
Regular
Sold Out
Unit Price
per 

Black Diamond & Diamond Halo Ring

Regular
$2,495.00
Sale
$2,495.00
Regular
Sold Out
Unit Price
per 

Oval Aquamarine and Round Diamond Rose Gold Ring

Regular
$2,529.00
Sale
$2,529.00
Regular
Sold Out
Unit Price
per 

Oval Blue Zircon & Diamond Halo Ring

Regular
$2,549.00
Sale
$2,549.00
Regular
Sold Out
Unit Price
per 

Oval-Cut Pink Tourmaline Oval & Diamond Sunburst Halo Ring

Regular
$2,549.00
Sale
$2,549.00
Regular
Sold Out
Unit Price
per 

Indicolite Blue Green Tourmaline & Diamond Ring

Regular
$2,549.00
Sale
$2,549.00
Regular
Sold Out
Unit Price
per 

Gray Oval Spinel & Diamond Ring

Regular
$2,579.00
Sale
$2,579.00
Regular
Sold Out
Unit Price
per