Colored Gemstone Engagement Rings

Show your creativity and individuality with alternative wedding and engagement rings and bands. Did you know that until recently, sapphires were the gemstone of choice for engagement rings? These days, the move to alternative gemstones is gaining popularity. 

Not a diamond and little white church kind of person? These unique non-traditional engagement rings are perfect for ANY individual style!

506 products

3 Stone Red Emerald and Diamond Classic Halo Ring

Regular
$2,995.00
Sale
$2,995.00
Regular
Sold Out
Unit Price
per 

Round Pink Tourmaline Rubelite and Diamond Halo Ring

Regular
$3,000.00
Sale
$3,000.00
Regular
Sold Out
Unit Price
per 

Fancy Cut Oval Blue Zircon & Diamond Nature Inspired Ring

Regular
$3,039.00
Sale
$3,039.00
Regular
Sold Out
Unit Price
per 

Cushion Cut Peridot and Vintage Halo Diamond Ring

Regular
$3,129.00
Sale
$3,129.00
Regular
Sold Out
Unit Price
per 

Natural Salt and Pepper Diamond & Diamond Ring

Regular
$3,129.00
Sale
$3,129.00
Regular
Sold Out
Unit Price
per 

Fancy Cut Pink Tourmaline & Diamond Halo Ring

Regular
$3,149.00
Sale
$3,149.00
Regular
Sold Out
Unit Price
per 

Oval Peridot & Classic Diamond Halo Ring

Regular
$3,179.00
Sale
$3,179.00
Regular
Sold Out
Unit Price
per 

Fancy Cut Morganite & Diamond Halo Ring

Regular
$3,195.00
Sale
$3,195.00
Regular
Sold Out
Unit Price
per 

Barrel Rhodolite Garnet and Diamond Lined Ring

Regular
$3,195.00
Sale
$3,195.00
Regular
Sold Out
Unit Price
per 

Oval-Cut Aquamarine with Unique Diamond Double Halo Ring

Regular
$3,195.00
Sale
$3,195.00
Regular
Sold Out
Unit Price
per 

Emerald-Cut Morganite & Diamond Double Halo Ring

Regular
$3,209.00
Sale
$3,209.00
Regular
Sold Out
Unit Price
per 

Fancy Cut London Blue Topaz & Sky Blue Topaz 3 Stone Style Ring

Regular
$3,249.00
Sale
$3,249.00
Regular
Sold Out
Unit Price
per 

Cat's Eye Tourmaline and Diamond Ring

Regular
$3,290.00
Sale
$3,290.00
Regular
Sold Out
Unit Price
per 

Marquise Shaped Red Emerald and Diamond Halo Style Splint Shank Ring

Regular
$3,295.00
Sale
$3,295.00
Regular
Sold Out
Unit Price
per 

Oval Blue Zircon & Diamond Filigree Style Ring

Regular
$3,295.00
Sale
$3,295.00
Regular
Sold Out
Unit Price
per 

Round Fancy Cut Morganite & Diamond Ring

Regular
$3,295.00
Sale
$3,295.00
Regular
Sold Out
Unit Price
per 

Emerald-Cut Tanzanite and Diamond Classic Style Ring

Regular
$3,295.00
Sale
$3,295.00
Regular
Sold Out
Unit Price
per 

Baguette Amethyst Diamond Lined Band

Regular
$3,295.00
Sale
$3,295.00
Regular
Sold Out
Unit Price
per 

Sapphire Centered Diamond Accented Engagement Ring

Regular
$3,330.00
Sale
$3,330.00
Regular
$3,330.00
Sold Out
Unit Price
per 

Round Peridot & Double Diamond Halo Intricate Style Ring

Regular
$3,379.00
Sale
$3,379.00
Regular
Sold Out
Unit Price
per 

Oval Ethiopian Opal and Diamond Halo Ring

Regular
$3,395.00
Sale
$3,395.00
Regular
Sold Out
Unit Price
per 

Oval Citrine & Double Diamond Halo Ring in Yellow Gold

Regular
$3,395.00
Sale
$3,395.00
Regular
Sold Out
Unit Price
per 

Oval Pink Spinel & Diamond Ring

Regular
$3,395.00
Sale
$3,395.00
Regular
Sold Out
Unit Price
per 

Baguette & Round Diamond Cluster Style Ring

Regular
$3,419.00
Sale
$3,419.00
Regular
Sold Out
Unit Price
per 

Oval Intricate Blue Zircon & Diamond Ring

Regular
$3,459.00
Sale
$3,459.00
Regular
Sold Out
Unit Price
per 

Rose-Cut Black Diamond & Diamond Halo Ring

Regular
$3,459.00
Sale
$3,459.00
Regular
Sold Out
Unit Price
per 

Oval Shaped Pink Sapphire Diamond Ring

Regular
$3,479.00
Sale
$3,479.00
Regular
$2,895.00
Sold Out
Unit Price
per 

Fancy Natural Yellow Diamond & Diamond Halo Ring

Regular
$3,495.00
Sale
$3,495.00
Regular
Sold Out
Unit Price
per 

Oval Cut Morganite & Diamond Double Halo Ring

Regular
$3,495.00
Sale
$3,495.00
Regular
Sold Out
Unit Price
per