Colored Gemstone Engagement Rings

Show your creativity and individuality with alternative wedding and engagement rings and bands. Did you know that until recently, sapphires were the gemstone of choice for engagement rings? These days, the move to alternative gemstones is gaining popularity. 

Not a diamond and little white church kind of person? These unique non-traditional engagement rings are perfect for ANY individual style!

327 products

  • Featured
  • Best selling
  • Alphabetically, A-Z
  • Alphabetically, Z-A
  • Price, low to high
  • Price, high to low
  • Date, old to new
  • Date, new to old

Filter by

    • Rings (326)
    • rings (1)

Green Sapphire and Diamond Square Ring

Regular
$329.00
Sale
$329.00
Regular
Unit Price
per 

Pink Sapphire and Diamond Square Ring

Regular
$329.00
Sale
$329.00
Regular
Unit Price
per 

Round Blue Sapphire Diamond Bezel Style Ring

Regular
$439.00
Sale
$439.00
Regular
Unit Price
per 

Oval Blue Sapphire & Diamond Classic Halo Ring

Regular
$469.00
Sale
$469.00
Regular
Unit Price
per 

Hexagon Shaped Peridot and Diamond Halo Ring

Regular
$509.00
Sale
$509.00
Regular
Unit Price
per 

Blue Sapphire Round & Diamond Ring

Regular
$549.00
Sale
$549.00
Regular
Unit Price
per 

Marquise Blue Sapphire and Classic Diamond Halo Ring

Regular
$549.00
Sale
$549.00
Regular
Unit Price
per 

Fancy Cut Pear Citrine and Diamond Halo Ring

Regular
$595.00
Sale
$595.00
Regular
Unit Price
per 

Round Emerald and Diamond Accented Band

Regular
$609.00
Sale
$609.00
Regular
Unit Price
per 

Fancy Round Cut Amethyst and Diamond Halo Ring

Regular
$629.00
Sale
$629.00
Regular
Unit Price
per 

Oval Blue Sapphire Solitaire Style Ring

Regular
$629.00
Sale
$629.00
Regular
Unit Price
per 

Blue Sapphire Marquise On Point Fashion Ring

Regular
$649.00
Sale
$649.00
Regular
Unit Price
per 

Amethyst and Diamond Half Halo Ring in Rose Gold

Regular
$669.00
Sale
$669.00
Regular
Unit Price
per 

Trillian Shaped Solitaire Garnet Ring

Regular
$719.00
Sale
$719.00
Regular
Unit Price
per 

Blue Sapphire Three Stone Oval to the Side Ring

Regular
$729.00
Sale
$729.00
Regular
Unit Price
per 

Sterling Silver Blue Topaz & White Topaz Cocktail Ring

Regular
$749.00
Sale
$749.00
Regular
Unit Price
per 

Three Stone Peridot and Diamond Halo Ring

Regular
$749.00
Sale
$749.00
Regular
Unit Price
per 

Pear Aquamarine and Diamond Accent Ring

Regular
$779.00
Sale
$779.00
Regular
Unit Price
per 

Round Cabochon Opal Ring with Diamond Halo

Regular
$779.00
Sale
$779.00
Regular
Unit Price
per 

Oval Citrine, Yellow Sapphire and Diamond Ring

Regular
$779.00
Sale
$779.00
Regular
Unit Price
per 

Cushion Cut Morganite and Halo Diamond Ring

Regular
$789.00
Sale
$789.00
Regular
Unit Price
per 

Oval Peridot and Diamond Milgrain Style Ring

Regular
$789.00
Sale
$789.00
Regular
Unit Price
per 

Checkerboard Blue Topaz Textured Style Ring

Regular
$795.00
Sale
$795.00
Regular
Unit Price
per 

Oval Cabochon Opal Ring with Diamond Halo

Regular
$795.00
Sale
$795.00
Regular
Unit Price
per 

Rose Gold Plated Fancy Shaped Amethyst with Diamond Halo Ring

Regular
$795.00
Sale
$795.00
Regular
Unit Price
per 

Sterling Silver Blue Topaz & White Topaz Cocktail Ring

Regular
$799.00
Sale
$799.00
Regular
Unit Price
per 

Cabochon Peridot & Diamond Halo Ring

Regular
$839.00
Sale
$839.00
Regular
Unit Price
per 

Round Peridot with Braided Band

Regular
$849.00
Sale
$849.00
Regular
Unit Price
per 

Blue Topaz and Diamond Halo Ring

Regular
$859.00
Sale
$859.00
Regular
Unit Price
per 

Sterling Silver Blue Topaz & White Topaz Cocktail Ring

Regular
$859.00
Sale
$859.00
Regular
Unit Price
per